"Silence can be the foundation of creativity; whilst the same silence uttered by the audience may splinter the spirit of a creative" - Self :)

Tuesday, September 29, 2020

ஙஞணநமன மெல்லினமாம்! - விமர்சனங்கள் (3)

ஙஞணநமன மெல்லினமாம்! - கிண்டிலில் வெளியான இக்கதைக்கான விமர்சனங்கள்/வாசகர் பார்வைகளின் தொகுப்பு இது. வாசித்து விமர்சனங்களைப் பகிர்ந்து ஆதரவு நல்கும் நண்பர்களுக்கு மனமார்ந்த நன்றிகள் 🙏!

Reviews from Amazon :

Reviewed in India on 2 July 2020
Excellent and unforgettable story as it takes readers also along with the flow.. feeling very close to heart as it touches reality to the core..
One person found this helpful
Comment Report abuse
Reviewed in India on 16 July 2020
Good novel briefing women problem in family life , how to overcome their problem, well written , expecting more novels
One person found this helpful
Comment Report abuse
Reviewed in India on 21 June 2020
Everyone woman would have come across the situations that are explained in the novel. Sarayu is very practical and Mithran is a very good husband to her..
One person found this helpful
Comment Report abuse
Reviewed in India on 8 July 2020
This novel reflected the inner thoughts and feeling I have under gone and it felt like having a heart to heart conversation.. Looking myself through someone else's eye. Excellent novel.. I enjoyed throughly..
Reviewed in India on 4 August 2020
I like this novel very much read twice, awesome narration able to visualize .Good family story in the author’s style. Must read
Reviewed in India on 2 July 2020
Thank you for writing this. I'll tell my friends about this story. The heroin in this story is like my character.so give 5 stars.
Reviewed in India on 22 July 2020
Loved this story.
Started very differently ended immensely truly. It will be useful for all ages to learn some thing or other
Reviewed in India on 5 July 2020
Very very nice novel..After a long time, really good novel..like the character of sarayu and mithran. Overall very good feeling.
Reviewed in India on 18 July 2020
The best book I've ever read. Worth of reading. Waiting more books from the writer. There are many women like sarayu
Reviewed in India on 19 August 2020
No words just awesome 🥰. Different story line good narration way to go mam. Expecting more stories like this mam

Reviews from Goodreads :

Veera
Jun 24, 2020 Veera rated it it was amazing
மெல்லினம்

வாழ்க்கையின் மெல்லிய நூலை அழகான கதையாக ஆசிரியர் நெய்துள்ளார். சரயு நம்மில் பலரை பிரதிபலித்தாலும், மாற்றங்களை அவள் அழகாக மாற்றி அமைப்பது அருமை.இக்கதையில் மெல்லினத்தின் வலிமையை நாம் உணரலாம்!
Sharmila
Jul 15, 2020 Sharmila rated it it was amazing
Nice novel

Good novel briefing women problem in family life , how to overcome their problem, well written , expecting more novels
 
----------------------------------
 
Ms. Nithya - Nov 26 2020
 
இதழ் வரி கவிதை is beautiful..
Nithyalakshmi Babu sent November 26 at 12:18 PM
ஓர் அன்பை ஒரு புன்னகையை ஒரு வாழ்த்தை ஒரு நேசிப்பை ஒரு பாராட்டை சின்ன மகிழ்ச்சியை...... I loved this..... A lovely story with lively ending...😀😀😀
 
------------------------------------
Ms. Ajudhya Kandhan - Dec 8 2020
 
இன்று உங்களுடைய ஸ்டோரி படித்தேன். னநமன மெல்லினமாம். மிகவும் நன்றாக இருந்தது எனக்கு பிடித்திருந்தது.. எனக்கு பொதுவாக கற்பனையான காதல் கதைகளை விட எதார்த்தமான குடும்பகதைகள் ரொம்ப பிடிக்கும் அந்த வகையில் மிகவும் நன்றாக இருந்தது.
 
------------------------------------
Ms. Premalatha Balasubramaniam - Dec 8 2020 
 
Hi, Recently I read your novel ஙஞணநமன மெல்லினமாம்.
I was actually intrigued by the title. படிச்சதும் மனம் கனத்து போச்சு. திருமணமான எல்லா பெண்களும் எதோ ஒரு காலகட்டத்தில் கதையில் வந்த சூழ்நிலையை கடந்து வந்திருப்பாங்க. அதை ரொம்ப அழகா இயல்பா சொல்லி இருந்தீங்க. எனக்கு நான் வாழ்க்கையில் சந்தித்த சில பேரை இந்த கதை நினைவு படுத்துச்சு. கதையின் முடிவு போல எல்லா பெண்களுக்கும் தெளிவு வந்தால் எவ்வளவு நல்லா இருக்கும்னு நினைக்க வச்சுட்டீங்க. Very good narration. இந்த கதை உங்கள் மற்ற கதைகளையும் படிக்கிற ஆர்வத்தை தூண்டி விட்டது. மனமார்ந்த வாழ்த்துக்கள். 

-----------------------------------
Ms. SS - March 5, 2021

Hi Mam, 
I am ****. Yesterday I read ur novel 'ஙஞணநமன மெல்லினமாம் '
First thing I was very surprised while reading... Ur way of conveying the feelings of human beings are really good and it's very close to reality. 
I wish to become a writer to write my own story as a novel.... God!  U wrote it under this topic.... Quite surprised... 
Is there really stories happening somewhere like this around me.... 
As I discussed with my friends they won't accept that my in laws are really like this which u described in this story.... 
Many incidents in my life  matches with this ...
My appa, Amma, Anna (instead of kavi...)... My husband.... 
Marriage, inviting in laws to home, husband transfer for job, post incidents, brother in laws visit to home with family, finally depression... Everything... 
Oh God.... Have u got get my story through my friend...!!! (just kidding)... 
Really happy to read this... Don't know why I was this much happy to read this story... 
Congrats for you... Wishes for u to proceed further more good novels  for long time... 
I am now in  ***************** with my husband after all those stuffs in life for past ten years... With two kids son n daughter (this too exactly like ur story).... 
Now realizing that phase of life is to teach me something in life which I  never got through anyone .... 
Very much thankful to u to make me feel that this is not happening for one but for many.... 
Finally one question Mam ... 
Will you please tell me how you got this story in ur mind  .... Just curious... If you wish... U can share... Take care mam... 
Thank you... 

No comments: